SpyShelter vs iDefender

We already talked about this a while back, but I wonder if you guys still have plans to beef up SpyShelter, to make it work more like SpyShelter Classic? Or are you guys done with it?

I mention iDefender because it’s a new HIPS/behavior blocker, which monitors a lot more stuff than SpyShelter. I’m afraid SpyShelter will not be able to protect against more advanced malware attacks at the moment. :roll_eyes:

I can’t speak for the SpyShelter roadmap, but a higher count of monitored events doesn’t automatically mean better protection; implementation, default rules, and false-positive handling matter more. If you want to evaluate iDefender, test it in a VM or on a spare system first, and avoid running two HIPS/behavior blockers together until you’ve confirmed they don’t conflict. That will tell you more about real coverage than feature lists alone.

I have to disagree. The way I look at behavior blockers (like SpyShelter and iDefender) is that they should monitor techniques that are often used by malware. So if iDefender monitors ‘‘process hollowing’’ and SpyShelter doesn’t, it means you will get better protection.

However, ease of configuration and GUI do play a big role. Also, with behavior blockers there is no such thing as false positives, I would like to be alerted about both trusted and semi-trusted apps. Of course HIPS shouldn’t interfere with normal operations of the OS.